Choosing someone to perform your baby's circumcision is one of the most important decisions you will make as a new parent. Whether you come from a religious background or are simply looking for the safest, most comfortable experience, finding the right mohel matters. Here is what to look for — and what questions to ask.
1. Look for Extensive Experience
The most important factor when choosing a mohel is experience. Ask how many circumcisions they have performed. An experienced mohel will have done hundreds or even thousands of procedures, giving them the skill and confidence to handle any situation. At My Home Circumcision, Rabbi Gadi Levy has performed over 2,000 circumcisions for families across the country.
2. Verify Their Training and Credentials
A qualified mohel should have formal training in circumcision technique, anatomy, and sterile procedure. Many mohels also have medical backgrounds or certifications. Do not be afraid to ask about their training — a trustworthy mohel will be happy to share their qualifications.
Rabbi Gadi Levy trained under some of the most respected mohels in the world and follows strict medical-grade sterile protocols for every procedure.
3. Ask About Their Technique
Different mohels use different techniques and instruments. Ask what method they use and why. The best mohels use time-tested techniques that prioritize safety, speed, and cosmetic results. The procedure should take under a minute in experienced hands.
Also ask about pain management — a good mohel will use topical anesthetic and sugar water (sucrose) to minimize discomfort, and the baby typically calms down within moments.
4. Evaluate Their Aftercare Support
Aftercare is just as important as the procedure itself. A great mohel does not just perform the circumcision and leave — they provide detailed aftercare instructions, a next-day follow-up call, and ongoing availability for questions throughout the healing process.
At My Home Circumcision, every family receives written aftercare guidance, a personal follow-up call, and direct phone access to Rabbi Levy for any concerns. For a complete look at what healing looks like, see our Circumcision Healing Guide.
5. Read Reviews and Ask for References
One of the best ways to evaluate a mohel is through the experiences of other families. Look for online reviews and testimonials. A mohel with consistently positive reviews from real families is a strong sign of quality and trustworthiness.
You can also ask your pediatrician, friends, or family members for recommendations. Word of mouth remains one of the most reliable ways to find a great mohel.
6. Make Sure They Serve Families of All Backgrounds
While the mohel tradition comes from Jewish practice, many families of all faiths choose a mohel for the specialized expertise and personalized care. Make sure the mohel you choose welcomes all families and does not require any religious affiliation.
At My Home Circumcision, we serve families of every background — Jewish, Christian, Muslim, secular, and interfaith. Every family is treated with the same warmth and professionalism.
7. Consider the Setting
One of the biggest advantages of working with a mohel is that the procedure happens in your home. This means your baby stays in a familiar, calm environment, and you avoid the stress of a hospital or clinic visit. Make sure the mohel you choose offers true in-home service and brings everything needed for a safe, sterile procedure.
8. Schedule a Consultation
The best mohels offer a free consultation before the procedure. This is your chance to ask questions, discuss your concerns, and get a feel for their personality and professionalism. A good mohel will be patient, transparent, and reassuring.
Ready to find the right mohel for your family? Book a free consultation with Rabbi Gadi Levy or call (773) 217-0073. We are here to answer every question and make this experience as comfortable as possible for your family.